The factual and procedural antecedents of these consolidated cases are as follows: The zoning ordinance, as corrected by the challenged Muntinlupa Municipal Resolution, classifies the subject property as 'institutional' where the operation of a grade school is allowed. 54438, which upheld the validity of a Muntinlupa Municipal Resolution correcting an alleged typographical error in a zoning ordinance. 144518 challenges the Court of Appeals’ Decision 3 dated Augin CA-G.R. 51096, dated Novemand July 2, 1998, respectively, which enjoined said school’s continued operation on the ground that the same is in violation of the Deed of Restrictions annotated on the title of the subject property that limits the use of the lot to the establishment thereon of a preparatory (nursery and kindergarten) school. 134240 assail the Decision 1 and Resolution 2 of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. COURT OF APPEALS (SPECIAL FIFTEENTH DIVISION), Respondents.Īt bar are three consolidated Petitions for Review on Certiorari all concerning the operation of a preparatory and grade school located in Ayala Alabang Village, more particularly on a parcel of land covered by Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) No. MUNICIPALITY (now CITY) OF MUNTINLUPA, THE LEARNING CHILD, INC., SPOUSES FELIPE AND MARY ANNE ALFONSO, AND THE HON. ERISSA ARCE, Petitioners,ĪYALA ALABANG VILLAGE ASSOCIATION, SPOUSES ERNESTO AND ALMA ARZAGA, MARIA LUISA QUISUMBING, ARTURO SENA, KSL CORPORATION and LAWPHIL, INC., Respondents.ĪYALA ALABANG VILLAGE ASSOCIATION, SPOUSES ERNESTO AND ALMA ARZAGA, MARIA LUISA QUISUMBING, ARTURO SENA, KSL CORPORATION, SLV MANAGEMENT CORPORATION and LAWPHIL, INC., Petitioners, ARCE, minor and represented by his parents RAPHAEL ARCE AND MA. SISON, minor and represented by her parents BONIFACIO SISON AND JOSEPHINE SISON and MATTHEW RAPHAEL C. WALMSLEY, minor and represented by his parents GERALD WALMSLEY AND MA. VELASCO, minor and represented by his parents FRANCISCO VELASCO AND ROSANNA VELASCO CHRISTOPHER E. AQUINO, minor and represented by his parents DR. FELIPE AND MARY ANNE ALFONSO, Petitioners,ĪYALA ALABANG VILLAGE ASSOCIATION, SPOUSES ERNESTO AND ALMA ARZAGA, MARIA LUISA QUISUMBING, ARTURO SENA, KSL CORPORATION, SLV MANAGEMENT CORPORATION and LAWPHIL, INC., Respondents.

Kindergarten 2 rule 34